Recital 26, Decision_act (EU) 1991/297

In forcesince 19 Dec 1990

On the occasion of the accession of the United Kingdom to the Community Solvay and ICI formally terminated the 'Page 1000` agreement with effect from 31 December 1972. According to the parties, a review of their contractual arrangements had shown that the agreement - which they say had already been considered out of date in 1962 - had never been formally cancelled. A letter of 12 October 1972 from Solvay to ICI is in those terms. An ICI board meeting of 26 October 1972 resolved that the 1949 minute confirming 'Page 1000` be cancelled. There is however some conflict between this minute, which repeats the statement contained in the Solvay letter that the arrangement had for a long time been considered 'outdated`, and a later ICI board minute of 26 July 1973 which states that letters of termination had been sent to Solvay 'after both companies` legal advisers had advised that the agreements contravened Article 85 of the Treaty of Rome and, if continued (1), would have to be notified to the EEC Commission'.

4.

The continued market separation in soda-ash between Solvay and ICI (27) The alleged desuetude of the 'Page 1000` arrangement did not however manifest itself in any significant change in the commercial policy of Solvay or ICI in the soda-ash sector, either in 1962 or at any later stage. Neither ever competed with the other in their respective home markets in the Community. Similarly in overseas export markets each continued to respect the other's sphere of influence. Indeed since 1984 Solvay has provided substantial tonnages to ICI by means of co-producer deliveries to enable it to maintain its position in South Africa, tradionally ICI's major deep-sea market and one in which Solvay does not itself market the product. (See recitals 36-38, post). ICI has also kept Solvay informed of its sales policy and intentions in Sweden, the one market of any importance where both producers are present. To all intents and purposes the respective commercial policies of the two producers in soda-ash have been maintained exactly as they were set out in 'Page 1000`.

The rigid market division in soda-ash may be contrasted with that now pertaining in caustic soda which was also the subject of 'Page 1000`. There are now a large number of caustic-soda producers in the Community and despite the handling risks it is freely transported across national borders. ICI now produces caustic soda in Germany as well as in the United Kingdom and operates stock tanks in France and the Netherlands from which it supplies customers throughout the Community. Solvay for its part operates a stock tank on Merseyside from which it supplies customers in the United Kingdom.

5.

The home market principle (28) Over many years all the soda-ash producers in Europe accepted and acted upon the 'home market` principle as the basis on which their commercial operations were determined.

Under this principle each producer limited its sales to (a) the country or countries in which it had established production facilities, (b) export markets in which there was no domestic producer. The other producers reciprocated by not selling into the 'home market` of that producer. In the event of incursions by an outsider into what a producer considered its home market, it was entitled and expected to 'retaliate` by selling an equivalent tonnage on the intruder's home market.