Recital 29, Decision_act (EU) 1991/297

In forcesince 19 Dec 1990

The documents obtained at several producers show that the protection of home markets by this means was for many years the subject of a general consensus in the soda-ash industry. Indeed the concept of 'retaliation` as a means of defending the home market was expressly provided for in a market-sharing agreement made between Solvay and Nederlande Soda Industrie (now AKZO) in 1956 (which is not the subject of any proceedings under Article 85). The 'home market` rule was strictly observed by all producers until the 1970s when declining demand and the appearance in continental western Europe of United States natural ash and east European material provided some element of competition. AKZO also began selling in the German market in the late 1970s since the Netherlands was too small a market to fill its available production capacity. Solvay had apparently indicated to AKZO its acceptance of this development without first obtaining the agreement of the smaller German producers. One of those affected therefore indicated to AKZO that it would begin to sell in the Netherlands and continue to do so as long as AKZO sold in Germany. In general, however, deliveries to customers across national borders (as opposed to co-producer sales) are still apparently considered by producers as an exception.

6.

The continuing Solvay-ICI relationship (30) Solvay and ICI have continued to maintain a close commercial relationship in the soda-ash sector. As the 'traditional industry leaders` in Europe they share an interest in maintaining the stability of the market. The two producers have maintained frequent contacts and meet each other to discuss matters of mutual concern in the soda-ash market. Up to the mid-1970s they exchanged detailed information on their production costs. The precise regularity and frequency of the meetings is not known but since 1985 they appear to have been held about every two months.