In spite of these price differences, there have been no significant movements of soda-ash in either direction between the United Kingdom and the Member States in continental western Europe, the only exception being tonnages shipped by Solvay as 'co-producer` deliveries to ICI. N° material has been sold by Solvay (or indeed any other Community producer) to customers in the United Kingdom, although price calculations found at the producers themselves show that even after the relatively high cost of transport from locations in continental western Europe the final delivered price to major customers (particularly in the south-east and east of England) would have been comparable to or even lower over a considerable period than ICI's price.
The only markets in continental western Europe in which ICI has ever supplied soda-ash in any appreciable quantity are the Scandinavian countries in which there is no domestic producer. It is significant that despite the transport costs involved in importing all the soda-ash consumed, price levels are considerably lower in Scandinavia than in those markets where there is an established soda-ash manufacturer.
The Alkali Cartel (22) Solvay and ICI have enjoyed close commercial links in the field of soda-ash and other chlorine-related products which go back to the 1870s when Brunner, Mond and Co., one of ICI's original constituent companies, became the first licensee of Solvay's ammonia-soda process and developed the manufacturing facilities in Cheshire which now constitute ICI Soda Ash Products.
The relationship between Solvay and Brunner, Mond included agreement upon their respective spheres of influence. The original market division was effected by means of the so-called 'Alkali Cartel`, an arrangement in respect of which the producers have not provided any information. It is not known exactly what commercial arrangements were made when the Solvay process was first licensed to Brunner, Mond. It appears however that new international market-sharing arrangements in the alkali field (including soda-ash and caustic soda) were made on a worldwide basis between ICI and Solvay in 1928 (soon after ICI was formed from Brunner, Mond and three other companies) and in 1935 and in 1938 between ICI, Solvay and I.G. Farben. Other cartel agreements were made in 1933 between ICI and Alkasso (the United States Alkali Export Association) and in 1936 between ICI, Solvay and Alkasso. These arrangements involved the allocation of exclusive markets to one or other party, the assignment of quotas in some other markets and the fixing of prices on a worldwide scale. The domestic market of each of the cartel members was considered vested in the home producer. (See: United States v. United States Alkali Export Association and Others, 86 F Supp. 559; 1948-49 Trade Cases No 62 474).