Recital 39, Decision_act (EU) 1991/297

In forcesince 19 Dec 1990

For its part Solvay appears, following Commission Decision 85/74/EEC (1) 'Peroxides`, to have been 'acutely sensitive to the perceptions of the market-place to any business relationship between chemical producers`, including PFR arrangements (ICI note of 15 February 1985). According to this note, Solvay was in general reluctant to supply on a direct basis to ICI either to markets where both producers were present or where the customer in question was a division of a pan-European group. Solvay was however prepared to make a number of 'compromises` or 'exceptions` particularly as regards markets such as South Africa and Ireland where it had no sales structure itself.

Although ICI seems originally to have presented these arrangements to Solvay as intended simply to overcome short-term production problems, it must soon have been apparent to Solvay that their purpose was to support ICI's long-term position in particular countries and thereby preserve the existing separation of markets between the two groups.

8.

The defence of Solvay and ICI (40) Neither Solvay nor ICI dispute (a) that in the Community there is little or no competition between them, (b) that in each case this phenomenon is the result of a considered and conscious decision by management.

They both assert however that their respective decisions not to compete were reached independently by each undertaking on purely commercial considerations and without any element of collusion or concertation.