Given that the concentration of the test chemical can decline over the period between medium renewals, it is necessary to consider what concentration should be chosen as representative of the range of concentrations experienced by the parent Daphnia. The selection should be based on biological considerations as well as statistical ones. For example, if reproduction is thought to be affected mostly by the peak concentration experienced, then the maximum concentration should be used. However, if the accumulated or longer term effect of the toxic chemical is considered to be more important, then an average concentration is more relevant. In this case, an appropriate average to use is the time-weighted mean concentration, since this takes account of the variation in instantaneous concentration over time.
Figure 1 shows an example of a (simplified) test lasting seven days with medium renewal at Days 0, 2 and 4.
The thin zig-zag line represents the concentration at any point in time. The fall in concentration is assumed to follow an exponential decay process.
The 6 plotted points represent the observed concentrations measured at the start and end of each renewal period.
The thick solid line indicates the position of the time-weighted mean.
The time-weighted mean is calculated so that the area under the time-weighted mean is equal to the area under the concentration curve. The calculation for the above example is illustrated in Table 1.
Renewal No. | Days | Conc 0 | Conc 1 | Ln(Conc 0) | Ln(Conc 1) | Area
1 | 2 | 10,000 | 4,493 | 2,303 | 1,503 | 13,767
2 | 2 | 11,000 | 6,037 | 2,398 | 1,798 | 16,544
3 | 3 | 10,000 | 4,066 | 2,303 | 1,403 | 19,781
Total Days: | 7 | | | | Total Area: | 50,092
TW Mean: | 7,156
Days is the number of days in the renewal period
Conc 0 is the measured concentration at the start of each renewal period
Conc 1 is the measured concentration at the end of each renewal period
Ln(Conc 0) is the natural logarithm of Conc 0
Ln(Conc 1) is the natural logarithm of Conc 1
Area is the area under the exponential curve for each renewal period. It is calculated by:
AreaConc0Conc1
LnConc0LnConc1
Day
The time-weighted mean (TW Mean) is the Total Area divided by the Total Days.
Of course, for the Daphnia reproduction test the table should be extended to cover 21 days.
It is clear that when observations are taken only at the start and end of each renewal period, it is not possible to confirm that the decay process in, in fact, exponential. A different curve would result in a different calculation for Area. However, an exponential decay process is not implausible and is probably the best curve to use in the absence of other information.
However, a word of caution is required if the chemical analysis fails to find any chemical at the end of the renewal period. Unless it is possible to estimate how quickly the chemical disappeared from the solution, it is impossible to obtain a realistic area under the curve, and hence it is impossible to obtain a reasonable time-weighted mean.