VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE SCHEME › F. Compatibility, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5

In forcesince 28 Oct 2009
(151)

Moreover it should be recalled that, when assessing whether aid can be deemed compatible with the common market, the Commission balances the positive impact of the measure in reaching an objective of common interest against its potentially negative side effects, such as distortion of trade and competition. The State Aid Action Plan, building on existing practice, has formalised a three-step ‘balancing test’. The first two steps address the positive effects of the State aid and the third addresses the negative effects and the resulting balancing of the positive and negative effects. The balancing test is structured as follows:

(a)

assessing whether the aid is aimed at a specific objective of common interest (e.g. growth, employment, cohesion, environment or energy security);

(b)

assessing whether the aid is well-designed to deliver the objective of common interest, i.e. whether the proposed aid addresses the market failure or other objective. For assessing this, it must be checked whether:

(i)

State aid is an appropriate policy instrument;

(ii)

there is an incentive effect, namely if the aid changes the behaviour of undertakings;

(iii)

the measure is proportional, i.e. if the same change in behaviour could be obtained with less aid;

(c)

assessing if the distortions of competition and effect on trade are limited, so that the overall balance is positive.