135 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE SCHEME › D. The Commission’s reaction to the comments received › D.3. Reaction to the comments on Article 58(1)(a) of the Treaty, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5

In forcesince 28 Oct 2009

The possibility granted to the Member States by Article 58(1)(a) of the Treaty, of applying the relevant provisions of their tax legislation which distinguish between taxpayers according to their place of residence or the place where their capital is invested, has already been upheld by the Court. According to case-law prior to the entry into force of Article 58(1)(a) of the Treaty, national tax provisions which establish certain distinctions based, in particular, on the residence of taxpayers, could be compatible with Community law provided that they applied to situations which were not objectively comparable [See, in particular, the judgment of the Court of Justice in Case C-279/93 Schumacker [1995] ECR I-225.] or could be justified by overriding reasons in the general interest, in particular in relation to the cohesion of the tax system [See the judgments of the Court of Justice in Case C-204/90 Bachmann v Belgian State [1992] ECR I-249 and Case C-300/90 Commission v Belgium [1992] ECR I-305.]. In any case, objectives of a purely economic nature cannot constitute an overriding reason of general interest justifying a restriction of a fundamental freedom guaranteed by the Treaty [See the judgment of the Court of Justice in Case C-120/95 Decker v Caisse de Maladie des Employés Privés [1998] ECR I-1831, paragraph 39; judgment of the Court of Justice in Case C-158/96 Kohll v Union des Caisses de Maladie [1998] ECR I-1931, paragraph 41; and the judgment of the Court of Justice in Case C-35/98 Verkooijen, already cited; paragraph 48.].

  • Judgment of the Court of 28 January 1992. Hanns-Martin Bachmann v Belgian State.Decision

    28 Jan 1992 · 61990CJ0204

  • Judgment of the Court of 28 January 1992. Commission of the European Communities v Kingdom of Belgium.Decision

    28 Jan 1992 · 61990CJ0300

  • Judgment of the Court of 14 February 1995. Finanzamt Köln-Altstadt v Roland Schumacker.Decision

    14 Feb 1995 · 61993CJ0279

  • Judgment of the Court of 28 April 1998. Nicolas Decker v Caisse de maladie des employés privés.Decision

    28 Apr 1998 · 61995CJ0120

  • Judgment of the Court of 28 April 1998. Raymond Kohll v Union des caisses de maladie.Decision

    28 Apr 1998 · 61996CJ0158

  • Judgment of the Court of 6 June 2000. Staatssecretaris van Financiën v B.G.M. Verkooijen.Decision

    6 Jun 2000 · 61998CJ0035

  • Treaty establishing the European Community58Law

  • case:eu=C-158/99
  • celex=31935D0098