128 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE SCHEME › D. The Commission’s reaction to the comments received › D.1. Reaction to the data extracted from the 2006 tax returns and to the comments about the judgment of the Court of Justice in Case C-501/00, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5

In forcesince 28 Oct 2009

As regards the data extracted by the Spanish authorities from the 2006 tax returns in order to demonstrate that the measure at issue is not selective [See recital 12.], the Commission underlines the general lack of precision of the information submitted. First, the data give the distribution of beneficiaries by category (activity, turnover), but do not indicate whether the beneficiaries concerned represent a small or large part of each of the categories concerned. Secondly, although statistics based on the size of the turnover of the beneficiaries could be an interesting indicator in order to demonstrate that the measure at issue applies to all companies in Spain, it must be underlined that the measure at issue is related to the acquisitions of shareholdings. This type of investment does not necessarily generate significant turnover, which implies, for example, that holding companies may be included as SMEs in the data in question. Therefore, for the data to be considered relevant, it would be necessary to take into account additional indicators, such as the total balance sheet figures, as well as whether the beneficiaries can consolidate their tax base with other Spanish taxpayers. Thirdly, the data also appear unrepresentative because they contain no indication of the level of shareholdings acquired (majority or only minority shareholdings) by the beneficiaries. Finally, the data received do not provide any indication making it possible to determine whether the conditions of the 2003 Commission Recommendation on SMEs are fulfilled [OJ L 124, 20.5.2003, p. 36.]. Therefore the Commission considers that its conclusion that the contested aid measure is selective due to the very characteristics of the legislation in question has not been challenged by the partial and unrepresentative data provided by the Spanish authorities.