115 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE SCHEME › A. Selectivity and advantage inherent in the measure › A.2. Additional reasoning: analysis of the measure at issue under a reference system consisting of the treatment of goodwill in transactions with third countries, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5

In forcesince 28 Oct 2009cited 2×

The Spanish authorities have explained that the objective of the measure at issue is to avoid a difference of tax treatment between, on the one hand, an acquisition immediately followed by a business combination and, on the other hand, a share acquisition without business combination. On this basis, the scope of the contested scheme would be limited to the acquisition of significant shareholdings in a company non-resident in Spain because some obstacles would make it more difficult to perform a cross-border business combination than a local one [See the e-mail of 16 June 2009 from the Spanish authorities cited in recital 13.]. As a result of these barriers, Spanish taxpayers investing abroad would be placed, legally and factually, in a different situation from those investing in Spain. Indeed, the Spanish authorities state that [See, in particular, page 6 of the Spanish authorities’ letter of 22 April 2009 (A-9531), cited in recital 9.]: ‘In summary, the mere differential nature of certain tax measures does not necessarily imply that they are State aid, since these measures also need to be examined to see whether they are necessary or functional as regards the efficiency of the tax system, as stated in the Commission Notice. Hence the Spanish tax system envisages different tax schemes for objectively different situations, as is the case for acquisitions of shareholdings in foreign companies as against acquisitions in Spanish companies (impossible to perform merger operations, risk management, etc.) with a view to achieving the tax neutrality imposed by Spanish domestic legislation and by Community law itself, and ensuring that the logic of the Spanish tax system is consistent and efficient’.

  • Opinion of Advocate General Pitruzzella delivered on 21 January 2021. World Duty Free Group and Kingdom of Spain v European Commission.Decision

    On 28 October 2009, the Commission adopted the decision at issue, by which it closed the formal investigation procedure in respect of acquisitions of shareholdings within the European Union. Having stated in recital 19 of that decision …

    21 Jan 2021 · 62019CC0051

  • Opinion of Advocate General Pitruzzella delivered on 21 January 2021. Banco Santander, SA v European Commission.Decision

    On 28 October 2009, the Commission adopted the decision at issue, by which it closed the formal investigation procedure in respect of acquisitions of shareholdings within the European Union. Having stated in recital 19 of that decision …

    21 Jan 2021 · 62019CC0052