5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.2. Compatibility of the aid › 5.2.2. General comments about the toll, Decision_act (EU) 2009/150

In forcesince 25 Jan 2006
(68)

The introduction of a distance-based user charge, recovering the costs of the infrastructure, is one of the key elements of the EC common transport policy:

First, the proposed introduction of the toll is in line with the Commission’s thinking on a more cost-related pricing structure in the European transport policy White Paper [European transport policy for 2010: time to decide, European Commission 2001, Table 3, p. 72.]. The White Paper contains a chapter concerning the gradual charging for the use of the infrastructure. The European Union is currently made up of a Europe of tolls, where users have to pay on toll motorways, a Europe of ‘eurovignettes’ paid by heavy goods vehicles throughout the entire network, and a Europe where no charges are applied at all. This situation can be improved.

Secondly, the replacement of user charges currently levied on heavy goods vehicles with a toll system could lead to a fairer share of infrastructure costs because a considerable proportion of the cost of motorway construction, maintenance and operation is due to heavy goods vehicles.

Thirdly, the toll will serve one of the objectives of the Community as mentioned in Article 2 of the EC Treaty, which is to promote a ‘high level of protection and improvement of the quality of the environment’.

Finally, considering the overall measure, it seems that the same applies to the potential advantages to be derived from shifting goods traffic from road to more environmentally friendly modes of transport. The change from a time-based motorway user charge to a mileage-based charge means that short distances become cheaper and long distances more expensive. This result does not only meet the need to make users bear a fairer share of the infrastructure costs, it also takes into account the fact that only on longer routes less polluting modes of transport (rail and waterway) offer an alternative to road transport.