Interested parties also expressed their doubts as regards the amount of the toll and its compliance with Article 7(9) of the Eurovignette Directive [See also Joined Cases C-430/99 and C-431/99 Sea-Land Service and Nedlloyd Lijnen [2002] ECR I-5235, paragraph 43 of the judgment and in particular paragraphs 85, 101 and 120 to 123 of the Opinion of Advocate General Alber, together with the case-law cited there.]. As the costs for the construction of the German motorways seem to be mostly depreciated, the calculation of the costs should mainly be related to the operating and developing costs of the infrastructure network concerned. In addition, it is argued that the toll system is discriminatory due to the fact that the toll will be levied by 100 % upon heavy goods vehicles of not less than 12 tonnes while — according to information provided by German authorities — they cause only 45 % of the costs. The exemption for private vehicles for tourism purposes also seems to be discriminatory. Furthermore, it is stated that the average toll rate of 12,4 cents/km seems to be too high. It appears that Germany uses the higher toll rate to cross-subsidise other transport modes which would violate both the ‘users-pay’-principle and Article 9(2) of the Directive 1999/62/EC.
39 3. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES › 3.1. Arguments against the reimbursement measure › 3.1.5. Additional arguments related to the toll system, Decision_act (EU) 2009/150
In forcesince 25 Jan 2006
Judgment of the Court (Sixth Chamber) of 13 June 2002. Inspecteur van de Belastingdienst Douane, district Rotterdam v Sea-Land Service Inc. Decision
13 Jun 2002 · 61999CJ0430
- celex=31999L0621