54 4. COMMENTS FROM THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY, Decision_act (EU) 2009/150

In forcesince 25 Jan 2006

The German authorities also argue that the measure is not discriminatory against those consumers of fuel using German motorways with vehicles of less than 12 tonnes. According to the German authorities, it is clear that the reimbursement is only given under the condition that the toll on lorries exceeding 12 tonnes is paid. Therefore, the reimbursement cannot be seen without the overall effect of a net burden for these lorries. Since, on balance, they will be charged more than they receive in return, it is difficult to argue that the reimbursement itself favours these vehicles above 12 tonnes, or, in other words, discriminates vehicles of less than 12 tonnes due to an alleged de facto discriminatory effect of a mineral oil tax reduction. Hence, in the view of German authorities, the reimbursement can not discriminate vehicles of less than 12 tonnes as they are not subject of the new toll system.