An additional argument presented by third parties is linked to a Court decision on an Italian aid scheme which consisted in a tax credit scheme for Italian road hauliers and provided for compensatory payments to be made to transport undertakings established in other Member States, on the basis of the estimated consumption of diesel required for the distance covered on Italian territory. The Court confirmed the Commission’s decision by which the Italian Republic was obliged to recover the granted aid. Therefore, interested parties argue, in analogy to the Italian case, that a difference in the tax burden for mineral oil cannot by itself justify the granting of State aid [In this context, interested parties refer to Case C-6/97, Italy v Commission [1999] ECR I-2981, in particular paragraph 21.].
28 3. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES › 3.1. Arguments against the reimbursement measure › 3.1.1. De facto discrimination of foreign road hauliers › 3.1.1.8. A difference in the tax burden cannot, by itself, justify the granting of State aid [See e.g. ASTIC, CEMT.], Decision_act (EU) 2009/150
In forcesince 25 Jan 2006
Judgment of the Court (Sixth Chamber) of 19 May 1999. Italian Republic v Commission of the European Communities.Decision
19 May 1999 · 61997CJ0006