In the view of the German government, the measure does not lead to a direct discrimination as the reimbursement is made available for all road hauliers, regardless of their nationality or residence. Neither does the measure leads to a de facto discrimination. First, they argue that there is a direct link between the new charge for the use of German motorways and the fuel consumption which again is directly linked to the amount of excise duties on fuel. In their view, the connection between toll reduction on the one hand and the payment of excise duties on the other hand is reasonably justified as both payments can be considered as a contribution to the cost of infrastructure. In addition, the measure does not foresee any thresholds, e.g. a minimum amount of toll charge or a minimum transport volume. Furthermore, the decision whether to fill the tank within Germany or not is a purely economic decision which will be taken by German road hauliers as well as by non-German road hauliers. All road hauliers will fill their tanks where they can see an economic benefit. In other words, the decision where to fill the tank is mainly influenced by the price of fuel. The German authorities argue in this respect that in Germany both the part of the excise duty on the fuel sale price and the sales price itself are among the highest in EU Member States.
47 4. COMMENTS FROM THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY, Decision_act (EU) 2009/150
In forcesince 25 Jan 2006