The fact that the German authorities argue that currently 50 % of the revenues of the excise duties is ring-fenced for infrastructure and the TRS is needed to avoid that hauliers will pay twice for the infrastructure does not prejudice to this conclusion. First, the final destination of tax revenues is not relevant in order to assess whether there is discrimination between German hauliers and hauliers from other Member States. The difference in the tax burden cannot justify the granting of aid, irrespective of the destination of tax revenues. Secondly, only 50 % of the revenues are ring-fenced for infrastructure and of this 50 %, a large share will be used to fund the infrastructure costs of the rest of the German road network for which no toll is required. Therefore, it cannot be held that — as the German authorities argue — hauliers that both pay toll and excise duties are paying a double contribution to the costs of infrastructure, as excise duties revenues are only marginally used to fund infrastructure for which toll is required. Consequently, the fact that the revenues of the excise duties are partially being used to fund infrastructure cannot justify the link between the toll reimbursement and the payment of excise duties either.
92 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.2. Compatibility of the aid › 5.2.4. Assessment of the compatibility with the common market › Non-discrimination, Decision_act (EU) 2009/150
In forcesince 25 Jan 2006