100 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.2. Compatibility of the aid › 5.2.4. Assessment of the compatibility with the common market › Necessity and proportionality, Decision_act (EU) 2009/150

In forcesince 25 Jan 2006

The Commission considers that the necessity of the aid has not been demonstrated. The German authorities argue that the measure has to be seen in the light of the transition actually being undertaken by the German authorities from a tax-based motorway charge to a mileage-based user charge. The Commission understands the wish to introduce transitional measures in view of the increase of the total charges for road hauliers, however notes that the level of the toll has been fixed at a lower level than initially planned, i.e. at 12,6 cents/km instead of 15 cents/km. Refraining from the intended increase of the toll rate would be a more straightforward way of compensating in a transitional period than increasing the toll rate up to 15 cents/km and at the same time, introducing the TRS and reimburse 2,6 cents/km. Moreover, the currently applicable lower rate equally applies to all road hauliers that use German motorways and is therefore non-discriminatory. The intended reimbursement would change this balance, which is not necessary to achieve the intended goal.