Recital 50, Decision_act (EU) 2002/643

In force

Under the test developed above, the Commission concludes that there was no State aid involved in the provision of DB's capital contribution as full cash deposit. DB AG acted like a commercial investor. DB AG gave its capital contribution as a full cash deposit, because it did not have any contribution in kind of value to the newly created joint venture. As explained above, BahnTrans acted solely as a freight consolidator and forwarder, not as a transporter. It was thus not appropriate to contribute rolling stock, equipment or trucks. DB AG did not contribute its real property assets to BahnTrans, as it was more economical to keep ownership of these assets and rent the land and eventual facilities to BahnTrans. Furthermore, change of ownership in real property would have given rise to real property sales taxes. Finally, DB AG as company fully owned by the Federation, is subject to Article 87e(3) of the Grundgesetz. This article prohibits the DB AG from selling transport-related assets to companies, in which it does not hold a majority of shares. As BahnTrans was owned by 50 % by THL, DB AG was thus legally not allowed to transfer any assets to BahnTrans. There was thus a further objective reason for it not to transfer any assets in kind to BahnTrans.