, Decision_act (EU) 1997/765

In forcesince 26 Jun 1997

In the end, the company did not fully implement the restructuring plan that was submitted to the Commission. At the time of evaluation of the plan by the Commission's expert (June 1996), the planned turnover for 1996 had decreased by DM 75 million. The company had planned on winning new orders worth DM 143 million that year, but the forecast was for only DM 78 million, of which no more than DM 30 million had by that time actually been contractually secured.

In the autumn of 1996 the management of SKET SMM proposed to the supervisory board a third restructuring plan which provided for a substantial reduction in both capacity and personnel. The employee representatives on the supervisory board rejected the plan and the management filed for bankruptcy on 15 October 1996.

In the light of all the facts set out above, the Commission has come to the conclusion that the following measures granted by the BvS are to be regarded as aid to which none of the exceptions laid down in Article 92 (3) of the EC Treaty apply:

>TABLE>

VI

In cases where aid is deemed incompatible with the common market, the Commission requires the Member State to recover the aid from the recipient (8). As this is the case with the measures in favour of SKET SMM which are the subject-matter of the present Decision, the aid must be recovered. This assessment of the situation is not altered by the fact that SKET SMM has since filed for bankruptcy and is no longer present on the market. The recovery is intended to compensate for the lasting effects on competition resulting from the granting of the aid. The recovery of the aid is not impossible since SKET SMM's assets will be sold and creditors will be satisfied out of the proceeds of the sale.

The recovery of the aid is subject to German law, including the provisions on interest due for late payment of amounts owing to the State, such interest being payable at the normal market reference rate from the date of the grant of the aid (9). In particular, the recovery claim must not be treated less favourably than claims resulting from acts of national public authorities.

In accordance with the case-law of the Court of Justice, the relevant provisions must be applied in such a way that the recovery required by Community law is not rendered practically impossible. Any procedural or other difficulties in regard to the implementation of the measure cannot have any influence on its lawfulness (10),

HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION: