By letter dated 16 January 1996 (registered on 17 January 1996) the German Government announced the failure of the intended privatization and the drawing-up of a new restructuring plan, and at the same time notified the provision of a DM 20 million loan to SKET SMM to ensure its liquidity until March 1996. By letter dated 13 March 1966 (registered on 15 March 1996) the German authorities withdrew the notification of the aid involved in the intended privatization which had not been granted prior to the failure of the privatization. By letter dated 14 March 1996 (registered on 15 March 1996) the German Government belatedly notified the provision of a liquidity loan of DM 60 million for the first quarter of 1996 and of DM 30 million for April 1996.
By letter dated 23 April 1996 (registered on the same day) the Commission was notified of the new restructuring plan for SKET SMM for the period 1996-98. The financial measures amounted to DM 352,1 million including the liquidity measures already notified for 1996. Following a request made by the Commission on 15 May 1996, the German authorities sent by letter dated 23 May 1996 (registered on the same day) the entire restructuring plan as devised by the Roland Berger consultancy.
The Commission received observations from third parties up to 9 November 1996. By letter dated 19 November 1996 (registered on the same day) the German authorities notified the granting to SMM of subsidies totalling DM 65 million since June 1996 and informed the Commission that DM 15 million of the April loan had been converted into a grant and that DM 61 million of the counter-guarantees had been called. They said that these measures were in line with the notified restructuring plan. By letters dated 30 January 1997 (registered on the same day) and 31 January 1997 (registered on 3 February 1997) the German authorities informed the Commission of the amount of guarantees and counter-guarantees called to date in accordance with the notified restructuring plan.
III
By letters dated 19 and 26 November 1996 the Commission transmitted to the German authorities the comments by third parties - a Swedish association of machine makers and an Italian and a German competitor - which it had received in response to publication of its decision to initiate the procedure. The observations by the Italian competitor concerning the extension of the procedure were received after the deadline for the receipt of comments.