, Decision_act (EU) 1997/765

In forcesince 26 Jun 1997

As stated above, there is intra-Community trade in the mechanical engineering industry, and in particular in the rolling mill and wire-rod mill sectors, where SKET SMM is predominantly active. The granting of aid to a manufacturer may thus distort or threaten to distort intra-Community trade. Competition between Community producers in markets outside the Community may also be distorted by altering the respective competitive positions of the individual Community operators.

According to a recent study carried out for the Commission, the European mechanical engineering industry is in recession. Owing to market dominance by east Asian producers, the Community's share of the world market fell from 47 % in 1986 to 40 % in 1994. The industry is currently aiming for greater specialization. It can therefore be said that the EU market is currently showing a tendency towards overcapacity.

Although the German authorities and the company challenge claims of low pricing, the Commission's independent expert came to the conclusion that in 1995 SKET SMM sold rolling mills at considerably below variable cost in three cases. Two of these cases involved orders from Asia (Jian Yin/China, Yu Din/Taiwan) and one concerned an order placed by a German customer (Freital/Saxony), the first two orders being the subject-matter of the first complaint to the Commission by the Italian competitor. These led to heavy losses that year (DM 106,4 million, compared to earnings of DM 55,8 million from these orders). The losses were clearly covered by the BvS (additional liquidity loan of DM 156,8 million to cover losses in 1995). Consequently, State aid was misused in order to acquire through aggressive, anti-competitive behaviour only part of the orders that were needed in order to fulfil the basic assumptions underlying the privatization plan. The granting of the aid was not a precondition for the anti-competitive behaviour, but it enabled SKET SMM to engage in low pricing.

Implementation of the restructuring plan

In the end, the company did not fully implement the restructuring plan submitted to the Commission, as described in the decision to extend the Article 93 (2) procedure. The investor pulled out in January 1996 after SKET SMM's operating results had badly deteriorated owing, among other things, to the marked reduction in orders.