The waiver of old debt, the granting of which was authorized by the first two Commission decisions on SKET SMM, resulted, not in any new liquid resources being injected into the company, but in the company's liquidity being maintained until the end of 1995, when the privatization failed. These measures have to be regarded as pure subsidies. The first debt waiver was exempted under Article 92 (3). As already indicated in the decision on the Treuhand arrangements (N 108/91), it was to be expected that the loans and guarantees of the THA to East German firms would de facto become grants the longer the companies remained financially dependent on the THA. It is accordingly logical to consider that the conversion of loans into grants constitutes additional aid. It can now be concluded, however, that these measures are covered by the abovementioned earlier Commission decisions on SKET SMM, which regarded it as a company in difficulties.
The waiver of the abovementioned new debt contracted in 1994 and 1995, the granting of which is not covered by the earlier Commission decisions on SKET SMM, constitutes an outright subsidy and is therefore to be considered new aid. The nominal amount of the aid is DM 269,4 million.
Loans
The BvS granted SKET SMM a supplementary loan of DM 156,8 million to cover all losses in 1995. The amount was granted in five instalments: DM 62,2 million at 6,8 % (DM 29 million on 13 March 1995, DM 30 million on 24 March 1995, DM 3,2 million on 24 April 1995) and DM 94,6 million at 5,4 % (DM 31,9 million on 19 June 1995, DM 62,7 million on 14 January 1995). A repayment deadline was not fixed.
The further liquidity loans granted between the failure of the privatization and the bankruptcy amount to DM 95 million: DM 20 million was granted in 1995 at an interest rate of 6,5 % a year, DM 15 million at an interest rate of 4 % a year and the remaining DM 16 million interest free and for an unlimited period. In all, up to the time of the bankruptcy SKET SMM was granted loans amounting to DM 251,8 million.
Since a provision of loans on market terms to a company in a financial situation comparable to that of SKET SMM is highly unlikely and since it conferred on SKET SMM a considerable financial advantage which it would not have gained under market conditions, the provision of the loans totalling DM 251,8 million has to be regarded as aid.
Grants