, Decision_act (EU) 1997/765

In forcesince 26 Jun 1997

The third parties expressed their concern both about the proportionality of the amount of the aid compared to its effect and about the viability of the company, even with the aid. The Swedish association argued that a non-viable company was being kept going with the help of a substantial amount of State aid in a market characterized by intense competition and a low rate of capacity utilization. All the third parties were concerned in particular about the misuse of State aid by SKET SMM - and one competitor in particular was concerned about misuse by H& B/DZM - to sell products below variable cost, the corresponding losses being covered by the State aid. SKET SMM was said to offer its products for sale at between 25 % and 45 % below the market price. The complainants gave several examples. It was objected that SKET SMM openly used the involvement of the BvS through aid to attract orders below cost price. This submission concerns exclusively orders from outside the EC, namely the Asia-Pacific area. It was argued that this behaviour was putting European competitors - in particular German and Italian producers - under heavy price pressure and was therefore threatening to distort competition in the Community.

IV

By letters dated 16 February 1996 (registered on 19 February 1996), 13 March 1996 (registered on 15 March 1996), 6 January 1997 (registered on 7 January 1997) and 9 January 1997 (registered on 30 January 1997) the German Government responded to the third parties' comments.

The specific examples given were disputed and other examples given where the Italian competitor had succeeded in winning the order. The German authorities commented on each example given. In some cases the orders had been placed with the Italian competitor, whereas in others they had been placed with SKET SMM, the counter-offers being in each case only marginally higher (no more than 5 %). The German Government argued that State aid was not being used to cut prices but to finance cost-cutting programmes. Furthermore, it said, SKET SMM was not present on the Swedish market.

Finally, the German authorities assured the Commission twice that since 1996 SKET SMM had been under strict instructions, following a resolution adopted by the company's shareholders, not to offer or supply its products at prices below direct cost except with the BvS's formal consent. Such consent had been neither requested nor given.

V