, Decision_act (EU) 1997/765

In forcesince 26 Jun 1997

In the Commission's experience, a company in a financial position comparable to that of SKET SMM in the industrial plant construction sector would have to pay approximately 3 % a year in order to obtain such guarantees on the open market. Consequently, the counter-guarantees provided by the BvS in favour of SKET SMM at an interest rate of 0,25 % a year on the maximum amount were not provided on normal market terms and therefore conferred a financial advantage on the company.

In view of the above, the provision of the counter-guarantees for performance and advance payment bonds at an interest rate of 0,25 % a year instead of 3 % a year must be regarded as aid (5), the aid element of which has to be defined by a cash grant equivalent.

The cash grant equivalent of the counter-guarantee has to be determined as in the case of a loan guarantee (6), that is once the premiums paid have been deducted, the interest subsidy representing the difference between the reference interest rate (3 %) and the rate obtained thanks to the State guarantee (0,25 %).

Waiver of debt

Between 1990 and 1992 the THA granted the then SKET AG a DM 90 million liquidity loan (subsequently reduced by DM 1 million) and guarantees worth DM 223,7 million. On 30 June 1993 the Commission decided (NN 46/93) that the prolongation of guarantees worth DM 201,7 million and the loan of DM 89 million (total of DM 290,7 million) were compatible with Articles 92 and 93 of the EC Treaty. A liquidity loan of DM 69,9 million and an investment loan of DM 67 million were also granted in 1993, which the Commission likewise exempted under Article 92 (3) of the EC Treaty (NN 95/93).

In 1994 all these measures were prolonged for one year and in 1995 they were waived as debt (including interest) in order to create equity (DM 361,7 million). The conversion of guarantees into loans (DM 201,7 million) and vice versa (DM 67 million, see below) was effected by the changing of positions between the BvS and the banks.