, Special Report No 1/95 on the cohesion financial instrument together with the Commission…

In forcesince 12 Jan 1995

3.8. The Treaty on European Union provides for financial support from the Cohesion Fund when a measure based on Article 130s, paragraph 1, involves costs deemed disproportionate for the public authorities of a Member State. In addition, the fifth Community programme for the environment lays down that the Fund's contribution is to be tied to the condition that projects must trace their origin to the Community legislation. However, the contribution of the financial instrument to projects that are concerned with the practical application of the directives based on Article 130s of the Treaty, and in particular those relating to the treatment of urban waste water (16) and waste (17), is somewhat limited. A number of small-scale projects concerning sewerage systems do not include the purification of the effluent.

Decision-making texts

3.9. Discrepancies between the different language versions of Regulation (EEC) No 792/93 and between the decisions to grant aid affect fundamental concepts such as commitment, payment and the deadlines for implementation. Following the Court's audit enquiries, the Commission was asked, in a letter dated 13 December 1993, to take the necessary measures to rectify the points mentioned above.

3.10. Moreover, the financing plans annexed to the decisions and the texts of these decisions do not always tally with each other. Thus, the financing plan for the project known as the 'Dublin-Galway railway link' (Ireland) stipulates that all expenditure will be carried out in 1993, and two thirds of the total amount of aid planned were advanced by the Commission. However, according to the text of the decision, most of the work will not be carried out until 1994. Part of the sum advanced was therefore paid out prematurely. Another example was noted in the case of a decision on a project in Spain, which on the one hand regarded expenditure incurred before 7 September 1993 as non-eligible, and on the other granted aid for the period from 1 February to 31 May 1993. This error has been corrected following an audit visit by the Court.