4.21. Sometimes, they show internal rates of return (IRR) for the projects which are low enough to justify their being financed, and the results of the analyses carried out by the EIB give lower, or even negative, IRRs. In the case of the water-supply project in Athens (Evinos), the preliminary studies showed the lack of rationality in the scale and the programming of the investments and the absence of reliable information. It proved necessary, moreover, to carry out a full hydrological study and an overall analysis of the water-resources management in the region. In spite of these studies, the Commission decided to finance the project (total cost: 196 Mio ECU).
4.22. The Commission has defined neither a suitable methodology nor minimum profitability thresholds. Consequently, the practical usefulness of the cost-benefit analyses, which are supposed to guarantee that the Community resources will produce economic advantages that are in proportion to the resources mobilized, is reduced.
4.23. The Commission has sometimes approved projects which have already been under way for several years, or even which ought to have been closed in financial terms. These projects already have adequate - national or sometimes Community - financial resources available for their completion. The Commission should make sure that the financial resources granted under the cohesion instrument do not encourage the recipient Member States to fail to stand by their undertaking not to reduce their investment efforts in the fields concerned.