, Special Report No 1/95 on the cohesion financial instrument together with the Commission…

In forcesince 12 Jan 1995

4.17. As for the management of the Structural Funds, the Commission must ensure that the amount of refundable VAT is not included in the eligible expenditure, as it does not represent a cost to the project. Moreover, as regards non-refundable VAT, there are grounds for considering that, with a rate of aid of 85 % and a normal minimum VAT rate of 15 %, the national contribution to the financing of the project can virtually be recovered in the form of fiscal revenue.

4.18. The audit enquiries have revealed, as capital expenditure, the cost of the acquisition of land. This cost represents 26 % of the total eligible cost of the 'Madrid ring-road between the N5 and the N6' project. Similarly, a project to restore Greek archaeological sites only includes expenditure relating to the compulsory purchase of buildings (26). In the context of the ERDF, the limit normally applied by the Commission for this kind of expenditure is 10 % of the total cost. It would be advisable to avoid granting large amounts of aid for the purchase of land and already existing buildings, the impact of which, moreover, in terms of value added, is usually modest.

4.19. Finally, experience has shown that in cases where the sites are not yet available, the deadlines set for the completion of the projects are almost never kept to because of the complexity and the slowness of the compulsory purchase procedures. The delays observed by the Court in the construction of the Madrid ring-road confirm these difficulties. This sort of situation leads to large amounts of resources advanced by the financial instrument being blocked on Member States' accounts.

The assessment of the projects

4.20. The Commission is required to assess the projects to see whether they comply with the criteria laid down in the Regulation. In particular, a cost-benefit analysis must be made. The Court's examination of the Commission's files produced no evidence to show that such a detailed assessment was always carried out. Analyses of this kind are sometimes missing. Where they exist, they have generally been carried out by the Member States, possibly after work has started, or even after it has been completed.