, Special Report No 1/95 on the cohesion financial instrument together with the Commission…

In forcesince 12 Jan 1995

5.3. The provisions of paragraph 12 of the Commission Notice C(88)2510 (28) to the Member States on monitoring compliance with public procurement rules in the case of projects and programmes financed by the SFs and financial instruments have remained a dead letter. This paragraph stipulates that, in the case of projects giving rise to contracts falling under sectors not covered by the directives in force, the recipient may undertake, in a specific clause, to open up contracts to Community competition. In addition, the Commission, in the same Notice, itself undertook, by way of an incentive, to give priority to aid applicants who open up contracts to Community competition, or who undertake in writing to do so.

6.

MONITORING

6.1. The monitoring has to be ensured 'by reference to physical and financial indicators' specified in the Commission decision approving the operations concerned. Scrutiny of the Commission decisions has not shown any physical indicator arranged in such a way as to show, for the operations concerned, 'the stage reached in the operation and the goals to be attained within a given timespan', and 'the progress achieved on the management side and any related problems' (29). This lack of indicators makes any monitoring and assessment of the financed projects difficult.

6.2. In order to assess whether a measure is progressing satisfactorily, the project or stage of project needs to have been identified perfectly from the beginning of the works, then in the request for aid, and finally in the decision. However, in the aid requests and in the decisions, the Court has frequently found descriptions of a very general nature, a fact which prevents any checking of the state of physical progress of the projects and its comparison with the forecasts.

6.3. The first requests for payment submitted by the Member States contained neither a detailed timetable for the completion of the works nor any monitoring indicators. This being so, the Commission did not make the intermediate payments within the time limits stipulated in the Regulation, and asked the Member States to provide the missing information. This request arrived late, and the Commission should not have taken its decisions to grant aid in the absence of monitoring indicators and a precise timetable for the completion of the work.

  • celex=31993L0038