, Special Report No 1/95 on the cohesion financial instrument together with the Commission…

In forcesince 12 Jan 1995

4.1. Projects, including groups of related projects, must be of a sufficient scale to have a significant impact in the field of environmental protection or the improvement of trans-European transport infrastructure networks (21). Nevertheless, the Court noted that very few of them can be regarded as being of sufficient scale to achieve the objectives of the instrument, with some being of an extremely small scale. For 30 projects the cost of implementation is less than 1 Mio ECU. Such projects should belong within the framework of other more suitable Community or national instruments. The projects to construct a car park at the airport of Hierro (Spain) (427 996 ECU) and two rail crossings at the port of Belview (Ireland) (725 000 ECU) are significant examples.

4.2. The inclusion of such projects in the cohesion financial instrument rather than in an operational ERDF programme seems to be dictated by the urgent need to select projects allowing rapid use of appropriations, and by the existence of a more advantageous Community rate of assistance than in the other structural measures. Achievement of the aims of the cohesion financial instrument does not therefore seem to be a high priority. An examination of the project-selection procedures in the Member States has enabled the Court to confirm this situation.

4.3. There is a danger that the objective of mobilizing the instrument's aid and the receipt of payments as quickly as possible may encourage the Member States to give priority to submitting small-scale projects which can be completed more quickly. That has an effect contrary to the provisions of the Regulation, which envisage the financing of significant projects.

The groups of projects