, Special Report No 1/95 on the cohesion financial instrument together with the Commission…

In forcesince 12 Jan 1995

4.11. These practices raise questions as to the value of the 1989-93 Community Support Frameworks (CSF) from which large parts have been removed in order to be financed instead by the cohesion financial instrument, where programming plays no role. Moreover, the breaking-down of the projects into stages could well make it easier to split up public contracts in order to avoid the application of the ceilings specified in the guidelines on this subject. Lastly, the splitting-up of projects into various stages makes it more difficult to monitor compliance with the provisions of Article 7 of the Regulation concerning the combination and overlapping of the assistance. The Court, with reference to the Commission's reply, points out that risks to which it refers, and the additional measures needed to overcome them, exist regardless of whether there are examples of situations where actual irregularities have been identified.

4.12. The technique of splitting-up the road projects into stages makes it possible to submit requests for aid for the stages that are most in conformity with Community provisions and to avoid the most doubtful ones. In the case of the Madrid M-40 ring-road (Spain), three projects were submitted and approved for a total cost of 277 Mio ECU without including a section of approximately 3 km, which was, however, located in the middle. This section gives rise to very considerable environmental problems because of the crossing of the 'Monte del Pardo', which has been made inevitable by the choice of routes for the adjacent sections. However, assistance to any project stage whatsoever obviously contributes towards the financing of the whole.

The revenue-generating projects

4.13. In cases where the transport infrastructure projects generate revenue, in particular airports, ports and toll motorways, the practice followed by the Commission is not consistent. In some cases, the cost to be financed was determined by deducting the estimated revenue. More often, this important financial effect was either taken into account in a flat-rate way to vary the rate of assistance between 80 % and 85 %, or ignored, with the result that public aid wholly finances an investment which could to a very great extent have been covered by the future income.