Recital 74, Decision_act (EU) 1992/553

In force

Even if retail brands can combine several local spring waters under one umbrella, these waters are not a sufficient alternative and counterweight to the national mineral waters according to the retailers themselves (see Annex 15). This strategy of combining several spring waters under one brand can only to a limite extent improve the position of the local waters but cannot change the fact that there is a long-standing and well-established demand for the national mineral waters (over 70 % of total demand). In addition, spring waters from different sources sold under retail brand are generally at the lowest end of the local still waters. These waters are not really sold to compete with, but rather to complement the major national brands. They are the less likely to be accepted as a reasonable substitute by those consumers who regularly drink national mineral waters. At best, the retail brands will be successful in that segment of the market where consumers are merely looking for a replacement of tap water by the cheapest drink or household water (the tap-water replacement segment).

According to Nestlé's declarations at the oral hearing, retail brands represent at most 7 to 8 % by volume (much less by value) of the total still water segment. Since the retailers have these waters bottled by local water suppliers, their volume is already mostly included in the market share of others. It is only exceptional that a retailer owns a source and bottles itself the water.

Local mineral waters cannot by law be marketed under a retail brand or under several different brand names. According to Nestlé's figures, local still mineral waters represent only 6,5 % of all still mineral waters against 93,5 % in the hands of the three national suppliers.