Additional barriers to entry
The high degree of concentration in the French source water market, with three companies holding 82 % of the market share by value, constitutes an additional barrier to entry and increases the risks associated with new entry (see recital 98).
The apparent failure of past attempts to enter the French market, together with the absence of imports confirms the actual economic impact of the barriers mentioned above. According to Perrier, there were 15 attempts at entry during the last five years. Only four are still present in the French market: Ferrarelle, which belongs to BSN, San Pellegrino, where Perrier holds a 20 % stake and has three of the nine members of the board of management, and Apollinaris and San Benedetto, which remain insignificant in terms of sales. According to food distributors' sources, while certain brands might enjoy an initial acceptance by the French consumer, consumers in general return to the well-known national brands in the short or medium term. The fact that the Belgian company Spadel directs its export effort to the UK rather than to France, in spite of the geographical situation of its source, further shows to the difficulties of penetrating the French market.