Recital 70, Decision_act (EU) 1992/553

In force

The volume losses of the three national suppliers in 1991 were small: 47 million litres for still waters and two million litres for sparkling waters. This represents only 1 % in the still water segment where the three suppliers together hold nearly 75 % of the market volume. Given the strong reduction in demand growth in 1991 following two exceptional years of growth, this loss is not the sign of a significant shift in demand in favour of the local spring waters. Also, the loss of sales of the national suppliers in 1991 is not necessarily or only due to competitive action of local spring waters because with a price increase of 7,11 % in 1991, Evian still gained a volume of 20 million litres. Volvic and Hépar, which also increased their prices, equally gained in volume, respectively 35 and 16 million litres. Only Contrex and Vittel lost in volume. Furthermore, it is not denied that a certain degree of competition exists between the national mineral waters and local spring waters. However, the above changes are not sufficient to show that local spring waters constitute a real competitive threat to the market positons of the three national suppliers. Even lively competition is not incompatible with market power as long as such competition does not compel the undertakings holding the market power to lower their prices (see the Court's judgment in Hoffmann-La-Roche, paragraphs 70 and 71, 1979 [ECR] 461).

  • Judgment of the Court of 13 February 1979. Hoffmann-La Roche & Co. AG v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    13 Feb 1979 · 61976CJ0085