Nestlé's representatives have argued that the level of exports to other areas should be taken into account in the market definition. According to Nestlé, price discrimination between France and the areas where it sells abroad is not possible, at least in relation to Belgium and certain German Laender. Therefore, its pricing in France would be restrained by the conditions prevailing in these other markets where Nestlé is present, although conditions of competition in these other markets are substantially different.
On this basis, and after an analysis of French exports of bottled source water to Belgium and Germany, Nestlé has submitted that the relevant geographic market should be extended to include Belgium and certain German Laender. It has argued that if excessive prices were to be applied in the French market, parallel imports into France would develop. The mere threat of parallel imports would jeopardize any dominant position in the French market according to Nestlé.
However, in view of the different competitive environment prevailing in each Member State, the practical impossibility of the development of parallel imports and the absence of Community competitors capable of overcoming the strong barriers to entry into the French market, the Commission concludes that the relevant geographic market is France.
A. Competitive environment in the Community