Production and marketing are subject to different constraints in the soft drink market and in the market of bottled source water in particular in France:
Regulatory requirements
the production of spring and mineral water is subject to authorisation (for mineral waters this can take between two and five years, see Goldman Sachs report, p. 16). Spring and mineral water has to be bottled at the source. Location of bottling plants is therefore subject to a major legal constraint which manufacturers of soft drinks do not have. Producers of soft drinks can locate their bottling plants according to an adequate balance between economies of scale and transport costs, a rationale water bottlers are not able to follow.
Manufacturers of soft drinks may and often do grant trade mark licences to independent bottlers who produce the soft drink in their own premises and sell the product under the original brand. According to industry sources, the soft drink industry has traditionally operated on the basis of national bottling/distribution franchises, although more and more the major companies tend to acquire controlling stakes in independent bottlers. In contrast, water from a given spring may only be bottled at the source. In addition, mineral waters (which represent over 75 % of the total French water market by volume), can only be marketed under the trade mark linked to their repective source, ie. mineral water extracted from a source has, by law, to be marketed under the trade mark registered for that source, and only water originating from that source can be marketed under that trade mark.
Different actors in each market
In France, no major soft drink producer (Cadbury Schweppes, Coca-Cola, Pernod Ricard) has been able to develop a presence in the market of bottled water, in spite of the past growth of demand and increasing manufacturers' prices for bottled source water. Similarly, the mineral water manufacturers do not have a major activity in the soft drink market (for instance, Perrier sold to Schweppes its Oasis still soft drinks in 1990, within an explicit strategy of focusing its business on the water market).
Manufacturers' pricing