, Decision_act (EU) 1986/398

In force

Further investigations, this time under Article 14 (2), were made to the selling agents of LINZ in Germany and the United Kingdom, to ANIC in Italy and to the United Kingdom subsidiary of SAGA Petrokjemi.

C. Evidence

15.

The main evidence on which the present Decision is based includes:

(a)

Detailed reports (normally headed 'personal - no copy to file') made by employees of ICI of a considerable number of meetings, (mainly from mid-1982 onwards, but including also some notes of earlier meetings in 1979 and 1981) with in certain cases detailed tables of the agreed 'target' prices for each major grade and in each European currency;

(b)

Reports made by an employee of Hercules which relate to two of the meetings for which ICI reports were also discovered (10 March 1982; 13 May 1982);

(c)

Internal ICI memoranda made by the employees who attended the meetings, dealing with matters which had been, or were to be, discussed in meetings, as well as assessments of the progress of the arrangements and the attitude of the other participants;

(d)

Internal accounting documents, travel orders, etc. which establish or confirm the presence of representatives of the different producers at most or all of the meetings known to have taken place particularly during 1982 and 1983. (It is significant that in the travel orders the real purpose of the visit was concealed, being described usually as a 'visit to customers');

(e)

Notes made by ICI of meetings between its representatives and those of Shell, Montepolimeri and (on occasion), Hoechst (the 'big four');

(f)

Documents found at ICI and Hercules - including some emanating from Italian or German producers - setting out full details of the European quota schemes from 1979 onwards;

(g)

Extensive planning documents made by ICI for the purposes of a new European quota system for 1983 together with notes made by ICI of the proposals of each of the producers and in some cases documents originating from such producers themselves - BASF, SAGA and Solvay - containing their own detailed proposals;

(h)

Documents obtained at ATO relating to the exchange of information on deliveries by the French producers in the EEC and the operation of quotas on the French market in 1979, as well as details of the European quota plan for 1980;

(i)

Documents found at ICI and at SAGA Petrochemicals (UK) Ltd (now Statoil (UK) Ltd) relating to local meetings in the United Kingdom where target prices were set;