The account of two meetings as given by ICI in its internal reports is confirmed in every material respect by notes of the same meetings found at Hercules.
Such documentation relating to the subject matter of the meetings (target prices, price initiatives, quotas) as was found at other producers (such as ATO, DSM and Shell) during the investigation also confirms the facts as set out in the detailed reports of ICI. Documents discovered at ICI but which originated from other firms provide further convincing evidence, particularly as regards volume targets or quota schemes.
The ICI reports were prepared for the use of senior directors of ICI Petrochemicals and Plastics Division who attended the bosses' sessions and acted as chairmen of the meetings. Given ICI's role as chairman of the group there is every reason to suppose that care was taken to ensure the reports were complete and accurate. The suggestion that these reports were a flight of fancy cannot be accepted.
The Commission therefore concludes that the reports of the meetings provided an accurate, reliable and consistent record of those meetings, the matters discussed, the agreements reached, and the role of the various participants.
The Commission does not have available records of each meeting that was held from 1977 onwards but records were found of certain meetings in 1979 and
1981 which show that the subject matter and result were essentially the same as those relating to 1982 and 1983.
Nature of the meetings
The available records of the meetings disprove the arguments advanced by the producers regarding the subject matter discussed and the allegedly limited extent of their participation. These documents show that agreement in detail was reached on the amount and timing of price initiatives and on the method of their implementation. As regards volume targets or quotas the numerous tables and calculations obtained which run from 1979 onwards contradict the claim that they were no more than 'proposals' which were never followed up.
The market study