, Decision_act (EU) 1986/398

In force

At the end of 1982 the 'big four' began to meet in restricted session the day before each bosses' meeting. These so-called 'pre-meetings' provided a forum in which the four major producers could agree a position between themselves prior to the full meeting. The idea was that the four major producers, with some 50 % of the market in their hands, could by adopting a united approach encourage moves towards price stability (source: ICI document headed 'Polypropylene framework'; Shell file note of 20 October 1982).

ICI has admitted that the topics discussed in pre-meetings were the same as those dealt with by the bosses' meetings which followed (source: ICI reply under Article 11), but Shell on the other hand has denied that the 'big four' meetings were in any sense preparatory to a plenary meeting or involved coordination on a common stance on topics to be discussed the following day. The records which exist of 'big four' meetings (in October 1982 and May 1983) however disprove this claim.

D. The factual arguments of the producers

69.

The factual arguments advanced by the producers during the course of the administrative procedure may be summarized as follows:

(a)

The record of the meetings: It is claimed that

the notes of meetings discovered by the

Commission at ICI are either not admissible

against other producers as proof of the facts recorded therein or are so unworthy of credence that no importance ought to be attached to them;

(b)

Nature of the meetings: While all producers admitted attending bosses' and experts' meetings (or in the case of Shell, 'big four' meetings) some producers claim that these were concerned only with general discussions of industry problems and never even touched upon matters affecting competition. Others admit that attempts were made to reach agreement on target prices or quotas but claim that no consensus ever evolved. Certain producers claim that whatever anti-competitive measures the other producers may have discussed or agreed at meetings they themselves were only present as 'observers' or to gain 'market intelligence' and for their part never committed themselves to any agreement or restriction of competition;