The economic survey of the German market does not disprove the existence of any agreement. Factors such as those invoked in the report - market structure and price transparency - could in the absence of evidence of collusion explain a general pattern of similar pricing behaviour. However, the Commission's objections are not based on general similiarities in the price conduct of each producer. Even if there had not been direct proof of meetings, the uniformity and simultaneity of the price instructions over a long period was so marked that it would on its own have given rise to a strong presumption of concertation. In the present case the evidence goes much further and establishes conclusively a link of causation between the commercial conduct of the producers and the system of regular meetings.
The Commission has in any event never maintained that the system of regular meetings controlled fully the operations and sales of the producers or was the only factor affecting the price levels of polypropylene. Indeed the evidence relied upon by the Commission shows that the producers recognized that the market was affected by matters such as changes in demand or raw material price increases beyond their control. In deciding upon the amount, timing, modalities and chances of success of a planned price initiative such market factors had to be taken into account by the producers. One of the main purposes of the meetings however was to try to coordinate the response of the
producers to such factors. It may also be that price was determined to a large extent by conditions of supply
and demand but the documentary evidence shows that by means of their volume control or quota systems the producers were attempting to manipulate those conditions.
The centralized audit
While there is no reason to doubt that the audit, conducted by a firm of independent accountants, accurately records the net achieved selling prices (after all discounts) of the producers concerned in the period covered, the Commission does not accept the conclusions the producers seek to draw.