, Decision_act (EU) 1986/398

In force

Hercules criticized the Commission for (it claimed) unfairly treating price instructions of different producers as contemporaneous when they were not. It drew particular attention to the lapse of at least 4 weeks between its price instructions of 26 July 1982 relating to an increase to 2,00 DM/kg with effect from 1 September and 2,10 DM/kg from 1 October and those cited by the Commission for the other producers. The instructions of the other producers were later because after Hercules had sent out its original telex it had been agreed to postpone the initiative by one month, and indeed Hercules itself sent out a telex on 24 August 1982 modifying the original instructions. More significantly, the first Hercules price instructions of 26 July ('For September and October we are seeking price increases based on

raffia targets of DM 2,00/kg and 2,10/kg respectively') were given only five days after it had attended the session of 21 July in which those very targets had originally been fixed (the ICI note of the

meetings reads: 'The DM 2,00 was generally accepted for September with a further 10 pfennig increase to be announced simultaneously for 1 October').

Independently of the audit commissioned by the other producers, Hercules produced a survey which purported to show no pattern of relationship between its own price 'guidelines' and the target prices fixed in meetings. This conclusion results largely from the omission or selective interpretation of price instructions and the use not of the actual targets fixed for each grade in the appropriate national currency (as set out in the tables attached to ICI's note of the meetings) but of inaccurate 'notional' figures extrapolated by Hercules for the purposes of the exercise from the DM raffia grade target.

77.

In some cases, the producers did not supply the Commission with a full set of price instructions from 1979 onwards as requested. Thus for two producers, Huels and Hercules, documentation was available only in relation to 1982 and 1983 and for Petrofina and Solvay in relation to 1983 only. It was claimed the documents for earlier years had been destroyed or never existed. The price instructions which were obtained show however that during the period or periods for which they made documents available these four producers were indeed taking action to implement the agreed targets.