, Decision_act (EU) 1986/398

In force

ANIC and Rhône-Poulenc provided no price instructions but the record of meetings and other documents show that these two producers participated regularly in meetings in which price initiatives were discussed and agreed. The documentation relating to the quota arrangements show that they were fully involved in those schemes during the period they were in the polypropylene market.

F. The involvement of each producer

78.

ICI, Montepolimeri, Hoechst and Shell as the 'big four' together constituted the nucleus of the arrangements which evolved from the 'floor price agreement'. After the system of regular meetings had evolved Montepolimeri assumed the leadership of the group, a responsibility which was ceded to ICI in August 1982. Hoechst, ICI and Montepolimeri were all regular participants in the bosses' and experts' meetings.

Shell did not attend these meetings but it was involved in the original floor price agreement, took part in ad hoc meetings with the other major producers and participated in the quota arrangements. On Shell's own admission prior to bosses' and experts' meetings its views were sometimes sought on the feasibility of price increases, and after such meetings it was informed by Montepolimeri or ICI that particular 'targets' had been proposed and passed on the information to its operating companies. Shell's internal documents confirm that it knew of and was participating in price 'initiatives', sometimes even as the ostensible leader. From the end of 1982 onward its representative regularly attended 'pre-meetings' of the four major producers. Operating companies of the Shell group took part in national meetings.

Apart from the 'big four' the other participants in the original 'floor price' agreement of mid-1977 cannot be identified with certainty. However, the later 1 December 1977 initiative by Montepolimeri, Hoechst, ICI and Shell had the express 'support' of Hercules, LINZ, Rhône-Poulenc, SAGA and Solvay at least. The participation of all these producers in collusive arrangements therefore dates from 1977, whatever the precise date on which each began to attend meetings.

The system of regular meetings began at about the end of 1977 but it is not possible to identify the precise date on which each individual producer began to attend (6).