Market study: The three German producers commissioned a study by an expert econometrist designed to demonstrate that conditions of vigorous or even ruinous competition obtained in the polypropylene market in Germany (taken as representative of the EEC as a whole), that the pattern of rises and falls in price and the persistent losses in the industry disproved the existence of any collusion and that prices were determined by natural market forces such as supply and demand balance, the general economic environment and fighting between producers for market share;
Centralized audit: The majority of the producers - ATO, BASF, DSM, Hoechst, Huels, ICI, LINZ, Montepolimeri, Petrofina and Solvay - also participated in a centralized audit by a firm of chartered accountants of their invoices for polypropylene for 1982 and the first nine months of 1983. The producers claimed that the audit disclosed wide variances not only between the prices actually achieved in the market place and the producers' 'list' prices but also from producer to producer and from customer to customer. From this it was argued that conditions of intense competition prevailed in the market place which disproved the existence of any real collusion between the producers;
Price instructions: All the producers argued that the written price instructions which they had issued to their sales offices showed variances both as to timing or as to the actual prices to be quoted in comparison with the alleged targets fixed in meetings and as between each other. Some producers sought to argue that notwithstanding their participation in meetings any apparent
similarity in their price instructions was explicable by factors such as market transparency (information from customers or press announcements) and the oligopolistic structure of the market.
Other particular arguments advanced by individual producers will be dealt with in the part of this Decision in which the participation and the extent of involvement of each in the alleged infringements is assessed.
E. The Commission's assessment of the producers' factual arguments
The record of the meetings
While offering various alternative interpretations of the nature and purpose of the meetings, the undertakings have not produced any documentary account of meetings or any oral evidence which might cast doubt on the accuracy of the ICI notes.