In July 1982, following informal approaches to the Commission from certain industry leaders, nine of the largest producers of thermoplastics were invited by the Commission to attend a meeting on the problems of restructuring the plastics industry: eight were producers involved in the present case: ATO; BASF; DSM; ICI; Hoechst; Montepolimeri; Shell and Solvay. The first meeting took place on 14 July 1982 and was attended by the chief executives of the producers and three Members of the Commission. The meeting agreed to set up a working group to produce a report for the Commission (the 'Gatti-Grenier' report) which contained proposals on capacity reduction for the thermoplastics LdPE, HdPE and PVC. This report was submitted at a second meeting between the Commission and several of the undertakings. The main conclusions were that a
'crisis cartel' was not warranted and that unilateral action or bilateral agreements to close surplus plants would meet the problems of the industry. None of the producers considered however that any substantial capacity reduction was required in the polypropylene sector. The Commission has always stressed (see for example the Second Report on Competition policy, points 29 to 31; Eighth Report, point 42; Twelfth Report, points 38 to 41; Thirteenth Report, points 56 to 61) that its approval for any joint measures for solving the problem of structural overcapacity depended on there being no unacceptable restrictions on competition such as price or quota fixing. This reservation has always been made abundantly clear to any producers proposing crisis measures.
B. Commission investigations
On 13 and 14 October 1983, Commission officials acting pursuant to Article 14 (3) of Regulation N° 17 carried out simultaneous investigations without prior warning at the premises of ten of the undertakings to which this Decision is addressed: ATO; BASF; DSM; Hercules; Hoechst; Huels; ICI; Montepolimeri; Shell and Solvay. A visit was also carried out at the premises of BP Chimie in Paris.
Following the investigations, requests for information under Article 11 of Regulation N° 17 were addressed to the producers supplying the western European market, including LINZ and SAGA. LINZ contested the Commission's jurisdiction and declined to reply to the request.