ICI and Shell admit that there were contacts with other producers as to how the price slide could be checked. According to ICI a price level may have been suggested below which prices should not be permitted to fall. It is confirmed by ICI and Shell that discussions were not limited to the 'big four'. A document dated 6 September 1977 found at Solvay shows that a meeting took place on 30 August 1977 between that company and Shell SA, the Shell Belgian company, in order to discuss the price of polypropylene. Hercules was also at least very well informed of the outcome of the price discussions. The identity of other producers involved in discussions at this time could not however be established.
Precise details of the operation of the floor price agreement could not be ascertained. However by November 1977 when the raffia price was reported as
having fallen to around 1,00 DM/kg, Montedison announced an increase to 1,30 DM/kg due to take effect on 1 December and on 25 November the trade press quoted the other three majors as expressing their support for the move with similar increases planned from the same date or later in December.
It was at about this time that the system of regular meetings of the polypropylene producers began. ICI claims that meetings were not held until December 1977 (i.e. after the Montedison announcement) but admitted that contact was occuring between producers before that date probably by telephone and on an ad hoc basis.
Shell says that its executives 'may have had discussions concerning price with Montepolimeri in or about November 1977 and Montepolimeri may have suggested the possibility of increasing prices and may have sought (Shell's) views on its reactions to any increase' (reply of Shell to Statement of Objections).
While there is no direct evidence of any group meetings being held to fix prices before December 1977, the producers were already informing meetings of a trade association of customers (EATP: European Association for Textile Polyolefins) held in May and November of 1977, of the perceived need for common action to be taken to improve price levels. Hercules in May 1977 had stressed that the 'traditional industry leaders' should take the initiative while Hoechst had indicated its belief that prices needed to rise by 30 to 40 % (source: EATP minutes).