The Commission decided to initiate the procedure provided for under Article 108(2) TFEU for the following reasons:
it appeared that the very levying of the tax involved State aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU, because it included refunds that did not seem to be justified by the logic of the tax system in place; furthermore, those aid elements did not seem justifiable in the light of the State aid rules applied in the agricultural sector,
the cessation of dairy production, financed, in particular, by the tax, could be partial or total; however, under the State aid rules applied in the agricultural sector, aid for the cessation of an activity may be declared compatible with the internal market only if all commercial farming activities are discontinued,
a part of the tax has been used to finance the destruction of milk contaminated by PCBs under a de minimis scheme based on Regulation (EC) No 1998/2006; however, it is not certain whether that Regulation was the appropriate legal basis for granting de minimis aid in this particular case, besides, choosing an inappropriate legal basis might give rise to State aid whose compatibility with the internal market has not yet been demonstrated,
the levying of the tax and aid for the cessation of activities might be incompatible with the common organisation of the market in milk or disrupt its operation; the State aid rules concerning agriculture specify that a measure having such characteristics cannot be declared compatible with the internal market.