Finally, as regards refunds, the French authorities point out that the ministerial decrees provided for the application of the refund scheme solely in cases where the surplus levy is payable by the producer under the special fiscal charge system (Taxe Fiscale Affectée, TFA) or the levy under Article 78 of Regulation (EC) No 1234/2007. In other words, the refund was applied as part of a penalty system, which cannot be compared to any preferential treatment of operators. If an overrun of the national quota were found, the refund would apply under Article 84(1) of the Regulation. Consequently, while the effects of the system varied for the different categories of operators, it did not distort competition between producers. Despite incurring a higher tax, a producer with the infrastructure and financial means to produce in excess of its quota was not disadvantaged compared to a producer who could not compete with that producer, despite a reduction of the tax rate. According to the French authorities, trade could not be affected either, because the taxation system was tied to a national production volume and, while the reduced rate allowed certain producers to produce more without any financial consequences, that was because other producers produced less. The quantity of milk finally placed on the market remained the same, and this did not affect trade between Member States.
28 IV. THE FRENCH AUTHORITIES' COMMENTS ON THE INITIATION OF THE FORMAL PROCEDURE, Decision_act (EU) 2018/341
In forcesince 27 Sep 2017
- celex=32007R1234