Recital 10, Decision_act (EU) 2004/114

In forcesince 29 Oct 2003

The Enkhuizen municipality decided, in 1998, to build a new harbour for large riverboats and tourist vessels. Because of the construction of this new harbour, the existing entrance of the sailing club KNZ& RV to the river was to be closed. In order to compensate for the closure of the entrance to the river the municipality took three measures:

(a)

the municipality provided a new opening to the river for KNZ& RV at a nearby location;

(b)

according to the municipality, the new opening forced passing boats to make a detour in order to reach the existing marina of KNZ& RV. According to an independent report (ordered by the municipality), the detour will lead to a 10 % decrease in the number of daily passing boats in the next 13 years. The total loss of revenue is calculated at EUR 80700. To compensate for this loss, the municipality dredged part of the water close to the existing marina, in order to enable the club to create 105 moorings at its own expense at a later stage. The Dutch authorities have provided an independent report in which the costs of the dredging of the future marina was compared to the costs for compensation of the loss of revenue due to the detour for passing boats. The total cost of the dredging was EUR 96655, which is approximately a similar sum of money as that of the loss of revenue due to the detour;

(c)

finally, the sailing club KNZ& RV was offered the opportunity to purchase the dredged area of water (26000 m2) from the municipality at the same price per m2 as the municipality had paid for the same area of water in 1998 to the national authorities. This price per m2 was determined by an independent appraisal report dated 30 March 1998, in which the appraiser concluded that this area of water (including a large part of the lake) had no economic value. According to the Dutch authorities, in that case, Dutch appraisers commonly use a basic value per m2, i.e. EUR 0,45 per m2. The total area of water acquired by the sailing club was 26000 m2, the total purchase price was thus EUR 11700 (26000 × 0,45).