Recital 56, Decision_act (EU) 2004/103

In forcesince 30 Jan 2002

The fact that, in circumstances such as those faced by Tetra, some financial loss may be suffered is inherent to the natural uncertainty that affects all merger transactions. Such natural uncertainty is part of any preventive merger control system. Before launching its bid, Tetra was aware of the French rules and of the Community rules and was thus aware of the risk that a prohibition decision might expose it to financial loss. This is made clear in Tetra's internal documentation which discussed the possibility of a prohibition decision by the Commission. In addition, Tetra was not obliged to enter into the transaction in the precise way it decided to follow, that is to say, by launching an unconditional public bid. Article 7(3) of the Merger Regulation allows for this possibility by providing an exception to the general suspensory rule in Article 7(1). However, the responsibility for the consequences, including financial ones, of such transactions remains entirely with the undertaking concerned. In essence, Article 7(3) merely gives companies wishing to acquire listed targets the possibility of launching an unconditional public bid. It does not oblige companies to follow this route. Whilst the French rules may be seen by Tetra as unnecessarily rigid in not allowing the launching of a conditional public bid, Tetra could have explored other legal structures in order to minimise potential risks.