Recital 38, Decision_act (EU) 2004/103

In forcesince 30 Jan 2002

A minority holding may also give rise to vertical concerns. Tetra is already a converter of HDPE bottles through "hole-through-the-wall" arrangements, whereby Tetra supplies customers with bottles produced in an adjacent location directly into the customers' production line and using its experience in carton and HDPE, could provide similar services producing PET bottles. Tetra is therefore a potential client of Sidel SBM high capacity machinery. This would enable Tetra to supply customers for sensitive products through a hole-through-the-wall arrangement. If Tetra were to hold a minority shareholding in Sidel it would have an incentive to favour the purchase of Sidel machines for its hole-through-the-wall activities. Given Tetra's position with carton customers, and thus potential PET customers for sensitive products, it is likely that it could also become a major player as a converter in the provision of PET bottles through hole-through-the-wall arrangements to producers of sensitive products. If it were to purchase only from Sidel, it could significantly boost Sidel's sales whilst at the same time foreclosing Sidel's competitors from supplying Tetra with SBM machines. This would increase Sidel's already strong position substantially and could raise its market position to the point of dominance. SBM competitors would therefore be foreclosed from supplying Tetra, in particular, and if Tetra were successful in capturing a significant number of its original carton customers for hole-through-the-wall operations a substantial part of the market could become foreclosed.