Recital 50, Decision_act (EU) 2004/103

In forcesince 30 Jan 2002

It is evident that none of the above precedents, which concern minority shareholdings in clearance decisions sanctioned a divestiture period of [more than three years]* as proposed by Tetra. Furthermore, in the special circumstances of an Article 8(4) decision following the prohibition of an implemented public bid, there should be no special obstacles to speedy disposal of the acquired undertaking as a going concern as it is a free-standing entity and, by virtue of Article 7(3) of the Merger Regulation has normally not been integrated into the business operations of the acquiring undertaking. The closest precedents, which Tetra has not discussed in its Reply are other divestiture orders pursuant to Article 8(4). There are only two such cases, Blokker/Toys "r" us (M.890)(18) and Kesko/Tuko (M.784)(19). In these cases divestiture periods ranged from six to nine months. Tetra has not provided any exceptional reasons as to why the Commission should depart from this practice in this case. Periods of the length proposed by Tetra would deprive the Commission's Prohibition Decision from its effet utile and cause harm to Sidel and competition. Tetra's assertion that the Commission's initial proposal for a six month period for divestiture is not in conformity with precedents is therefore not correct.

(b)

Preservation of the value of Tetra's EUR 1,7 billion investment in Sidel