Recital 27, Decision_act (EU) 2004/103

In forcesince 30 Jan 2002

In principle, a divestiture has to restore conditions of effective competition in a final and permanent manner(11). Thus, an appropriate divestiture mechanism should not contain artificial legal structures enabling Tetra to buy back the shares at a later point in time dependent on the eventual outcome of litigation. No company could function effectively with such uncertainty as to the eventual owner of 95 % of its shares. A non-final divestiture structure enabling Tetra to regain control of Sidel at a later point in time, would distort Sidel's competitive behaviour during the transitional period. Sidel would be unable to make strategic decisions such as major investments or significant acquisitions without taking into account the fact that, at a later point in time, Tetra might regain control of the company. Sidel would, in effect, be removed from the market place as an independent player for the duration of the transitional period. Sidel would be managed with a view to maximising value in the short term rather than taking long-term views which only a buyer with unfettered freedom of action could take. Sidel would also, in effect, be removed from the market as a target of acquisitions. For instance, no industrial buyer could buy the Sidel shares during the transitional period with restrictions allowing Tetra to regain control. This was confirmed by Tetra at the Oral Hearing.

Conclusion